I chose the Primo oval because of it's extra capacity. I've got three small boys now who are going to eat me out of house and home in a few years. I knew the other ceramics would be big enough to handle most things but the extra space coupled with the extra racks is really nice. I also use the firebox divider to do smaller indirect smokes. I'm sure you'd be happy with any of the ceramics, but I'd buy another oval if I had to do it over again. Made in the USA wasn't the deciding factor but it is a plus to me.

SmokinCy - Primo Forum